Amish Paste vs San Marzano Tomato: Know Your Preference

It’s confusing to choose between so many varieties of tomatoes. Growing to make a sauce, or a paste, or even adding to your salad you need to choose one heirloom.

It’s never easy for a first-timer or even a regular grower. Confusion grows when two similar kinds of tomatoes like Amish Paste and San Marzano are your options.

So we need to understand the differences that exist in Amish Paste vs San Marzano Tomato.

Amish Paste and San Marzano tomatoes are both sweet. But San Marzano comes with a tangy flavor. Amish Paste is comparatively larger with more meat. The growing time of these two types is almost three months. But Amish Paste can be eaten in many ways.

Well, this is just a preview. Read along for an instructive debate so that you can choose what you prefer by the end.

Notable Dissimilarities Between San Marzano and Amish Paste

We have gathered four basic factors for your ease. Let’s educate ourselves on the basic dissimilarities between Amish Paste & San Marzano.

FactorsAmish PasteSan Marzano
TasteSomewhere between sweet & Tangy.Meaty texture with a sweet flavor.
ShapePlum shaped, and large. Fat and Normal tomatoes are available.
GrowingMany seeds are available and easy to grow.Not popular among seed savers. 
ServingGreat for salad, sauces, paste, and purees.Best for pizza sauce.

To know more about these factors in detail jump into the head-to-head battle.

Amish Paste vs San Marzano Tomatoes: Head-To-Head Battle

Amish Paste Vs San Marzano Tomato

Before you jump into the head-to-head battle, you need to acknowledge a few facts. First of all, know what you will be using your tomatoes for.

Knowing this will make your way to choose easier. 

It may seem impossible to differentiate these two tomatoes if you are a new grower. But you don’t need to worry because we have described this in simple terms.

To clear out all of your confusion jump into the details of all the notable dissimilarities.

Taste Test

You heard it right! Amish Paste and San Marzano have different tastes. It is slightly similar as both of these are the same fruit.

Amish Paste tomatoes have a balanced taste of sweetness and acid. It provides a pleasant taste.

If you slice the Amish Paste tomatoes fresh you will not get any tangy flavor. But making a salad or a paste with this tomato will give you that tangy flavor.

But San Marzano is kind of different from the other type of tomatoes. These are popular for their sweet flavor. 

San Marzano tomatoes are as delicious but they are not great for picky chefs. Their meaty and sweet taste is suitable for pizza sauce and other sweet dishes.

On the other hand, Amish Paste can give you both sweet and tangy flavors.

So, if you are looking for both sweet and tangy you can go for Amish Paste tomatoes.

Winner: Amish Paste 

Shape & Texture

Shape of the tomatoes matters for easier skinning and growing. Tomatoes come in various shapes and sizes.

Amish Paste tomatoes are big. They are plum-shaped juicy tomatoes. These tomatoes are mostly 8 to 12 ounces.

These tomatoes are paste-type fruit. Amish heirloom has mostly thick flesh.

On the other hand, San Marzano is a narrow and oval-shaped fruit. The length of these kinds of tomatoes is not more than 3 inches.

So, San Marzano is comparatively small. It means it contains less flesh.

Well, Amish Paste also wins as it is bigger in shape and can give you more meat.

Winner: Amish Paste


With the perfect amount of tending and care any tomatoes can be cultivated easily. So let’s know which kind of tomatoes will be better for cultivating.

Amish Paste tomatoes are grown in the same manner as any other tomatoes. But you need to preserve the seeds to plant for the next season.

Mature Amish Paste tomatoes will be juicy and thick. This large fruit will take time to grow.

However, Amish Paste tomatoes need not more than 3 months to become mature. 

But, San Marzano tomato plants are a fast-growing plants. You can make these mature indoors within 85 days.

So, you get thick, meaty tomatoes within three months if you choose Amish Paste.

Amish Paste or San Marzano, whatever you choose you should use some products to defend the plants from rotting.

We have gathered these amazing products for your plant to defend it from diseases. Check them out!

Winner: Amish Paste


Some tomatoes are great for eating raw, and some are better in form of sauce or paste.

Amish Paste tomato can be eaten fresh in salads. But you can also make a paste and still enjoy the full flavor of this tomato.

But if we look at the San Marzano it’s better if you use it for a sauce. Because raw tomatoes of this kind will give you a sweet but tart flavor. 

This might be a huge deal if you are a picky chef. This slight change might not even matter to many but some of use like our raw tomato sweet.

Winner: Amish Paste

Who’s The Winner?

sweet and tangy Amish Paste tomato

Are you still thinking about which tomato to go for? Well, don’t. The pieces of information we provided will all lead you to one result. And that is Amish Paste tomatoes.

On a hot day, fresh slices of Amish Paste tomatoes can change your mind in a second. 

Amish Paste tomatoes will surprise you with a fresh sweet flavor and its meaty texture. Salad or Paste, it’s best in all forms.

Well, that was all the information we had for you today. We hope you understood who won the battle. Now you know why you should go for Amish Paste tomatoes.


Is San Marzano a paste tomato?

San Marzano is easy to skin with high yields. It has a low seed count. Making a paste of these kinds of tomatoes is not so tough. San Marzano is great for pizza sauce and spaghetti sauce.

In which place does San Marzano grow the best?

As San Marzano is an Italian tomato it grows best near Mount Vesuvius, Italy. But you can indeed plant and grow San Marzano seed in the United States or other areas. But you should be careful when you purchase a canned San Marzano.

What is the outcome of Amish Paste Seeds Planting?

Amish Paste tomato produces large seeds. The result of growing these fruits is surprising. You will be rewarded with heavy fruits with the richest and thickest sauces. After planting Amish Paste seeds it will take three months till you can taste a juicy and thick fruit. 


Well, now all you need to do is decide between Amish Paste vs San Marzano tomato. We have shown you all the outcomes so that you can choose your preference.

One last tip. Whichever tomato you choose, make sure to protect it from getting rotten if you’re growing.

That’s it for today!

If you have any further questions, let us know in the comments.

James Rivenburg
James Rivenburg
James Rivenburg

James Rivenburg is the founder of, a passionate gardener with valuable experience and knowledge gained through trial and error. The website has a large community of followers who trust his tips and techniques and have succeeded with his advice. He is always Committed to helping others create a beautiful and healthy garden.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *